There are two ways to transform real-life characters into big-screen drama.
The filmmaker can greatly embellish, turning true grit into an enlightening, but entertaining night of movie drama.
Or, as director Joe Wright does with "The Soloist," the story can be played close to the story-arc vest.
Although well acted by Oscar-winner Jamie Foxx ("Ray") and Oscar nominee Robert Downey Jr. ("Tropic Thunder," "Iron Man"), "The Soloist" orchestrates a one-note drama and a longsuffering, explosive tone sure to have moviegoers squirming in their seats.
Screenwriter Susannah Grant, herself an Academy Award nominee for "Erin Brockovich," opts for reality over entertainment. From this aisle seat, that exposes an odd couple friendship forged as a nightmare-like roller coaster ride of two unlikely friends united primarily by demons.
Steve Lopez (Downey), a Los Angeles Times metro columnist haunted by deadlines, a busted marriage and, in the early going at least, a busted face (due to a bicycle spill), happens upon a homeless man playing a violin. The violin is down to two strings. Nathaniel Ayers (Foxx), who keeps his over-stuffed grocery cart within arm's reach, has been mugged 14 times hanging onto it.
Truthfully, there must be around 90,000 homeless person stories in L.A. because that's how many lost souls wander the Skid Row streets once the sun sets below the palm trees.
Lopez is enchanted by Ayers once he picks up through Nathaniel's rapid chatter babble something about attending Juilliard as a music prodigy back in his youth.
What works best about "The Soloist" is the tightening bond between two very different men and how their relationship changes them both. I like the way Wright, who also called the shots on "Atonement," maintains an equally tormented tone between two driven men. Neither is likely to improve much. Nathaniel will have nothing to do with medication that could help his sometimes violent mental condition.
Lopez fights his own demons (the shaky, volatile state of the newspaper), while constantly battling to "fix" someone probably destined to play his beloved Beethoven concertos in a traffic tunnel instead of a concert hall no matter what.
I can't put my finger on exactly why this happened to me, but there's something about this tale of raging emotional bulls that never quite pulled me fully into the story. Foxx and Downey are two of my favorite actors. Even so, I saw actors at work here much of the time instead of original characters on the screen.
And something else: You need to know that this will not be two hours of lighthearted "Rain Man" (1988) entertainment. Though Nathaniel rattles on verbally much like Dustin Hoffman did winning a best actor Oscar as Raymond, the autistic savant, "The Soloist" never once sugar-coats a serious medical condition to lighten the load with laughs.
The same thing happened in October with "Flash of Genius." Greg Kinnear did everything right as Bob Kearns, the inventor who took on Detroit automakers for stealing his intermittent windshield wiper invention. That one stuck basically to the desolate facts and suffered at the box office for keeping reality real.
Sometimes, sad stories are simply that: sad stories.